Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Bitter is The Whine

Normal 0

Who likes sour grapes? Not me. I’m usually the first one to poo poo sour grapes, based solely on principal. Are these sour grapes I offer? I don’t know, I guess I’m not sure how objective I can be about this.

I live in Youngstown, Ohio

As many know, prior to the late seventies, Youngstown was a flourishing steel town, well endowed with old money. In such a climate, art, and culture tend to thrive. When local American steel companies moved to Japan, it was the death of Youngstown. To make that statement locally, is sacrilege.  The people who remain either turn a blind eye, or try to have hope beyond reason. Youngstown currently has less than sixty percent of it’s densest population. It’s estimated that every third house in Youngstown is abandoned. The city of Youngstown caught national attention by making the unprecedented motion of abandoning whole neighborhoods, and sections of town, declaring them, “no longer a part of the city of Youngstown. In the year 2000, The city elders unveiled their, “Youngstown 2010” initiative, outlining the ten year path of recovery, and prosperity for our city. As time passed, that dream faded. Now that it’s 2009, no one really mentions, “Youngstown 2010.” Last I heard, it’s been reshaped into a directive to convert, “grayspace” to “greenspace”. That amounts to replacing abandoned buildings with trees. I guess that is a, “recovery” of the most basic sort.

Among those who would like to deny that they live in a ghost town, are those that cling to the notion that art is not dead in Youngstown. With the exception of The Butler Institute of American Art, art is indeed dead in Youngstown. The Butler is a true institution, in that it is a hold out from better times, and has managed to stand in these grim times.

Aside from The art gallery in The Butler, who is proven to be supportive of local artists, there is only one remaining art gallery. I’m not stupid. Times are tough in the best of places. This is one of the most impoverished places in the country. I know the market for selling art locally is small to nonexistent. Be that as it may, being an at least adequate local fine artist with a reasonable body of work, I felt it would be good, and worth while to try to schedule an exhibition at the only independent art gallery left. I’m not what most would consider an established artist, I’m self-taught, and lack credentials. I’ve always felt that credentials were only important to automatons, and lackeys. I think the proof is in the putting.  I put together a proposal for a solo exhibition as per the gallery’s guidelines and submitted it. I felt confident and certain that it was the first step towards a mutually rewarding alliance, and perhaps a statement, that amidst this desolation, hope springs eternal, and art can happen anywhere someone expresses it. I believed that the lofty whispers of those who say interest in Youngstown artists can be nurtured, could ring true.

“Thanks for entering your artwork for consideration, however the committee sees rarely an opportunity for a one artist exhibition”. That’s what the form letter said. I’m not really sure what that means aside from the obvious. Everyone rues rejection, but it’s more the implications of the rejection that I find troubling.

I have a general philosophy that can be summed up in a couple of my favorite quotes:

“Far better it is to dare mighty things, to win glorious triumphs even though checkered by failure, than to rank with those poor spirits who neither enjoy nor suffer much because they live in the gray twilight that knows neither victory nor defeat.”-Theodore Roosevelt.

The U.S. Army Officer’s Training manual states, “Any plan, no matter how poorly conceived, if boldly executed, is better than inaction”. I’ll have my exhibition. It will be in Cleveland, or Pittsburgh. I have a great deal of confidence in a better future through art for myself. I’m sorry I can’t say the same for Youngstown.

Posted via email from pooch posterous

2 comments:

Tyler said...

I hope you'll attend Thursday's Rust Belt to Artist Belt discussion at Butler North next to the Butler at 4pm: http://tylersclark.com/blog/2009/06/rust-belt-to-artist-belt/

Have you reached out to the Oakland? They frequently have single-artist exhibits in their gallery space, though it might be smaller than you're hoping for.

I don't agree that no one talks about 2010 any more, though it's really a platform on which to move forward, which hopefully will define our principles in how we do business and in what decisions are made.

Obviously, the national economic slump has put a pinch on state and federal dollars that can help do demolition work, and no doubt that has slowed things down a bit.

Jeff Puccini said...

Hi Tyler,
Thank you for taking the time to read my blog. I had intended to attend the discussion today, mostly because I'm utterly intrigued with the concept. I've heard about similar initiatives in other places such as Oil City Pa. The notion seems ideal and utopian, however I lack the depth of understanding of how such things could work practically. Unfortunately, after driving through high water last night, the car wouldn't start.
I reached out to The Oakland to the extent that I tried to find out who to contact, and couldn't, so I went there, and tried to see what it was all about. The door was open, but it was very dark. I called out and no one answered. I went downstairs and around back, where I found a person, and inquired if there was indeed an art gallery there abouts. He said, "Sort of". Then he explained that while it's not open to the public, there is sometimes art displayed, and can be viewed when there is a production. I haven't followed up, I probably should, but I can't help but to feel a bit discouraged.
As 2010 goes, please don't misunderstand, personally, I like the notion of bulldozing the urban blight in favor of green-space, I just don't feel that it is conducive to economic, or cultural recovery. I guess I may have gotten it wrong, but I thought those were the original goals of the 2010 initiative.